Gengar
PSA 5 · 1st Edition estimate
$416
- Recent sales: middle of the last 3: $416, Oct 5 to Oct 13
- Evidence: moderate · 17 sales we counted in the last 90 days · last sale Oct 13
- Next-sale range: $352 to $563
Updated Oct 20, 2026. Estimate, recent sales and next-sale range: all adjusted to typical eBay auction prices.
How close we came: half of 54,208 sales were within 11 percent of our estimate the day before. Group: Wizards era, 9 or more sales in 90 days, Jan 1, 2025 to Oct 16, 2026. See how close we came for similar grades
How we got this
A full estimate: 17 sales we counted in the last 90 days, weighted toward the most recent.
Recent sales: the middle (median) of the last 3 sales we counted (Oct 5 to Oct 13), each adjusted to typical eBay auction prices: Buy It Now and auction-house prices are moved by the gap we measure between venues in this era. The sales list shows the prices paid.
Checked on 54,208 estimate-to-next-sale pairs for grades with 9 or more sales in 90 days, Wizards era, from Jan 1, 2025 to Oct 16, 2026: half the next sales landed within 11 percent of the estimate at the time (as of Oct 18). A record of past estimates, not a guarantee for this card.
Estimates with moderate evidence had a median error of 11 percent on 57,634 past cases (Jan 1, 2025 to Oct 16, 2026).
Sales in the last 90 days ran from $105.50 (Oct 13) to $549.99 (Oct 8) (17 sales, prices paid).
Evidence: strong means at least 4.5 effective recent sales (older and clustered sales count for less) with a spread under 0.15; moderate, at least 2.8 with a spread under 0.30; limited, anything less. The basis (sales of this grade, or estimated from similar cards) is stated separately.
An estimate from completed sales. Not an offer or an appraisal.
PSA 5 · 1st Edition · Apr 23 to Oct 13
One low sale
The latest sale, on Oct 13, was about 74 percent below the 24 sales before it. The sales before it were not.
Our estimate has not moved with them yet: $416 on Oct 12, $416 now.
What this label means
Only the latest sale is far below the earlier price. Far means at least 25 percent lower and 2.5 times the usual spread. The sale before it was not.
The earlier price is the middle sale of this grade in the 180 days before these sales.
The usual spread is how much this grade's price moves from one sale to the next.
Labels describe past sales only. They never change our estimate.
Sales, last 90 days
17 sales plotted · adjusted to typical eBay auction prices
Tap a dot, or tab to it, to see that sale.
Prices are adjusted to typical eBay auction prices. The latest sale is ringed.
About this chart
Log scale: the highest sale is more than 4 times the lowest, so equal steps on the price axis are equal percentage changes.
Buy It Now and auction-house prices are moved by the gap we measure between venues in this era, so every dot is comparable with an eBay auction. Tap a dot to see the price paid.
Estimate history, last year
Gengar · PSA 5 · 1st Edition · 1 year
Dots are sales at the price paid. The line is our estimate, adjusted to typical eBay auction prices. From Oct 17, 2026, each point is the estimate we published that night. Before Oct 17, 2026, the points were rebuilt later from past sales.
Last point on this chart: Oct 20, 2026, estimate then $416. Adjusted to typical eBay auction prices.
Thinking of buying?
Gengar · PSA 5 · 1st Edition
Thinking of selling?
eBay Buy It Nowyou keep about $384
eBay takes $60 (13.25%) plus $0.40.
Fanatics Buy Nowyou keep about $377
Fanatics takes $24 (6%).
Alt fixed priceyou keep about $362
Alt takes $36 (9%).
eBay auctionyou keep about $355
eBay takes $55 (13.25%) plus $0.40.
Alt auctionyou keep about $344
Alt charges no seller fee and adds a 4% bonus to the $337 winning bid.
Fanatics auctionyou keep about $340
Fanatics charges no seller fee and adds a 2% bonus to the $339 winning bid.
Card showabout $333 (dealers often pay around 80%)
No fees. Dealers often pay around 80% of value. We do not measure their offers.
After fees and about $6 postage, at today's estimate of $416.
Goldin is not shown: we do not measure Goldin prices for this era.
How we got this
eBay: the estimate plus the shipping you charge, less eBay's fee on both, less the per-order fee and your postage. The Buy It Now row uses the Buy It Now estimate. Fanatics, Goldin and Alt auctions: the estimate moved to that venue's prices with the gap we measure for this era, divided by one plus the buyer's premium to get the hammer price, then the seller bonus added or the commission taken off, less postage. Fanatics Buy Now and Alt fixed price: that venue's price less its seller fee and postage. Show offer: the estimate times your percentage. Sales tax is left out; eBay also charges its fee on tax the buyer pays. fees as of Oct 19, 2026.
- eBay auction: Trading card fee: 13.25% of the sale up to $7,500. Above that, 2.35% on the rest. The sale counts the price, shipping charged and sales tax. Each order also pays $0.30, or $0.40 over $10. Sales tax is left out here. Checked Oct 19, 2026 (confirmed). Source
- eBay Buy It Now: Same fees as the auction, on the Buy It Now estimate. That is our estimate times this era's usual Buy It Now gap, never below the estimate. Checked Oct 19, 2026 (confirmed). Source
- Fanatics auction: Buyers pay a 20% premium on the hammer price. Our stored Fanatics prices include that 20%. Premier Auction, for cards worth $25,000 or more: the seller gets 110% of the hammer. That rises to 112.5% above $250,000 and 115% above $1,000,000. Weekly Auction: a bonus of 2% to 15% on sales of $50 or more. We use the lowest, 2%. There is no seller fee. Checked Oct 19, 2026 (partly confirmed). Source
- Fanatics Buy Now: Seller fee 6% when listed under 120% of Card Ladder's market value. It is 12% at or above that. Buyers pay no fee. We list at the Fanatics price, so 6% applies. Checked Oct 19, 2026 (confirmed). Source
- Goldin auction: Buyers pay a 22% premium, at least $19. Goldin does not publish its seller commission. About 5% is a typical figure, not confirmed. We do not measure Goldin prices yet, so this route has no figure. Checked Oct 19, 2026 (partly confirmed). Source
- Alt auction: Buyers pay a 20% premium. Sellers pay no fee. The base seller bonus depends on the card's value: 4% under $1,000, 6% to $5,000, 8% to $25,000. It is 10% to $50,000, 12% to $200,000 and 15% above. We use the hammer price for the value. We assume our stored Alt prices include the premium. Checked Oct 19, 2026 (confirmed). Source
- Alt fixed price: Base seller fee: 14% to $249, 9% to $7,499, 7% to $9,999, and 5% from $10,000. Buyers pay no fee. Checked Oct 19, 2026 (confirmed). Source
- Show offer: No fee. Your own percentage of the estimate. The default follows the evidence: 87.5% strong, 80% moderate, 67.5% limited. Checked not checked (not applicable).
Grades · PSA · 1st Edition
Grades 1 to 3 share one estimate. Their recent sales overlap, so we do not rank them apart.
Estimates are adjusted to typical eBay auction prices. Sold ranges are prices as paid. A dash in the 30-day change column means no change is shown: it needs strong or moderate evidence.
How we got this
A grade's estimate needs 5 or more sales we counted in 90 days; otherwise the panel shows the lowest to highest sale of the last year. When neighbouring grades' sales overlap, or a lower grade's figure would sit above a higher grade's, they share one precision-weighted estimate (each figure weighted by how tight its range is). The 30-day change compares with the last settled estimate and shows only with strong or moderate evidence.
Printings · PSA 5
Sales, last 90 days, PSA 5 · 1st Edition
17 sales we counted · prices as paid
Tap a sale for its record, with the price adjusted to typical eBay auction prices.
$105.50Oct 13
$549.99Oct 8
$450.00Oct 5
$405.00Sep 30
$450.00Sep 27
$525.00Sep 22
$503.28Sep 22
$367.00Sep 15
$450.00Sep 14
$420.00Sep 11
Report a missing sale
On eBay now
Listings from eBay, updated Oct 20, 2026, 00:17 UTC (3 hours ago)Current offers at asking prices. These are not completed sales.
$599.00Buy It Now · Best offer1999 POKEMON FOSSIL 1ST EDITION #5 GENGAR-HOLO PSA 5Seller feedback 845,361 (99.9% positive)View on eBay
Prices and stock as eBay lists them. eBay is not part of this site.
PSA population
PSA 5: 590 copies graded
Source: Scrydex, report as of Oct 20, 2026. Check PSA's population report
Other grades (16)
| Grade | Copies | |
|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | 183 | |
| PSA 9 | 1,999 | |
| PSA 8.5 | 72 | |
| PSA 8 | 2,370 | |
| PSA 7.5 | 5 | |
| PSA 7 | 1,386 | |
| PSA 6.5 | 4 | |
| PSA 6 | 938 | |
| PSA 5.5 | 2 | |
| PSA 5 · selected | 590 | |
| PSA 4.5 | 3 | |
| PSA 4 | 236 | |
| PSA 3 | 92 | |
| PSA 2 | 39 | |
| PSA 1.5 | 2 | |
Related
